I'm That Witch

I'm That Witch is a spooky original musical about Clara, a young woman searching for where she belongs. When the Hecate summon her into a magical world where a coven of witches is trapped inside an evil circus ruled by a tyrannical White Rabbit, Clara—guided by a mischievous Black Cat— discovers she's the key to their freedom. As the witches reclaim their voices and break free from the forces controlling them, they forge an unbreakable chosen family built on resilience, belonging, and collective strength.

With an original score and a boldly female-driven story, I'm That Witch reclaims the word "witch" as a symbol of feminine power, autonomy, and community, leaving audiences feeling empowered, connected, and thoroughly entertained.

This musical is a 65-minute fully produced show with original music by Sturkey and Studabaker and directed and choreographed by Andrea Palesh and Melissa Buriak of GPC Entertainment. The team heavily utilizes dance, music, costumes, and props to tell the story. Pulling inspiration from their cabaret background, the show creators embrace venue and technical limitations to tailor the show to the environment.

It’s Hocus Pocus, meets Alice in Wonderland, meets The Nutcracker.

• Music and Musicals
• $20.00 + $2.50 fee - $30.00 + $2.50 fee
• 18-October 25, 2026
• 60 minutes
• Under St Marks
• 94 St Marks Pl, New York, NY 10009