Theater, Theatre - Co-Productions, Season 28

If We Really Were Witches

What would’ve happened if real witches dropped in on the witch hunts? Comedy, we’re sure. Summoned by the ghost of a witch hunt victim, real witches Mildred, Agnes & Suds arrive to rescue innocent Obediently Snead and serve up a little justice of their own. When challenged by The Pricks of Puritanical Piety Guild and Social Club, the real witches turn the tables on those who abuse their power to harm others out of ignorance and fear.

This four-person 60-minute comedy self-identifies as "The Crucible Meets Monty Python" and is headed over to The Edinburgh Festival Fringe in August of 2026.

Get access to
    • Special Events
    • $20.00 + $2.50 fee
    • May 9, 2026-July 19, 2026
    • 60 minutes
    • Under St Marks
    • subvenue 94 St Marks Pl, New York, NY 10009
    Event Image

    Book your tickets for If We Really Were Witches

    Choose date

    • Selected
    • Available
    • Unavailable
    • Low Availability
    • Selected
    • Available
    • Unavailable
    • Low Availability
    Select Tickets

    Book your tickets for If We Really Were Witches 


    Back to event

    Select ticket type for

    Loading Seatmap...

    Book your tickets for If We Really Were Witches 


    Back to event


    Select ticket type for

    Venue

    Under St Marks

    94 St Marks Pl, New York, NY 10009

    2026 All rights reserved. Powered by